it is sad to admit i have never found time or to my interest to play sc campaigns..but i have played war3 campaigns and ithink war3 campaigns turned out better than sc ones...thats my opinion though

Yeah the SC campaigns are too repetitive...

__________________
Tell Your Friends About StarCraft2.net! Help StarCraft2.Net Become A Big Hit!

Warcraft campaign seems much more complex then the current Starcraft campaign. Also, much better graphics with a lot of cut scenes add to a nice visual storyline.

Yes, overall, I'd say WarCraft III is the real winner in this topic.

__________________
Tell Your Friends About StarCraft2.net! Help StarCraft2.Net Become A Big Hit!

i feel that sc campaigns lack the plot... in addition wc3 has nice interludes...

the SC campaigns were a little soft, but I think SC still wins being a better game in general. The feel of playing the campaign, and simply doing starcraft is such a better experience than playing WC3... I am shocked at these results, considering you are all members of a SC forum! Have some respect for the classics.

in life we must be realistic... perhaps all of us like SC... however sometimes we cant let our emotions do the talking...

so wise...
It isn't emotion, it is just opinion. I feel that the starcraft campaigns were better, just because they were more fun, because the game was better. I liked the characters better, the style of the game, the graphics (WC3 is too cartoonish I think), and just the gameplay in general.

i guess blizzard cant help with the graphics... since 3D rendering do make the characters look like toys... on all your other points i guess it is just a matter of opinion... sry if i misinterpreted your post...

no you got it pretty much right. The cartoony look took the coolness out of warcraft 3, and your right it is all about opinion.